Search the site · Ask Zorva

Results appear as you type. Press Enter and Zorva answers from this site’s own pages.

Local SEO

Answering a Bad Review Without Breaking RPC 1.6

A Tennessee lawyer was censured in 2025 for answering Google reviews with client details. How to reply safely, and what else a firm's pages must carry.

May 24, 2026Updated October 14, 20266 min read
Zorva before a grid of connected site panels over an outline of Tennessee (illustration)
TL;DR

In 2025 a Tennessee lawyer was publicly censured for answering Google reviews with confidential client details, so a firm's review replies need a written habit before anything else. The post then covers the 2021 advertising rules (responsible lawyer named, two-year copies, no 'specialist'), the thirty-day solicitation limit, and how Google treats lawyers' profiles.

Picture the review. One star, posted late on a Friday by a former client who says you took the retainer and then stopped returning calls. You remember the file differently. You know what was paid and when, the hearing they missed, the voicemails you left. The reply box sits right under their words.

That box is where a Tennessee lawyer recently got into the kind of trouble no ad ever caused her. According to a release from the Board of Professional Responsibility, attorney Cindy Powell Bice received a public censure on January 14, 2025. She had answered a client's negative Google review with confidential details: payments, a contempt action, a hearing date, her communications with the client. The release says she'd answered four more reviews the same way between 2015 and 2023. The rules it cites are RPC 1.6(a), 1.9(c) and 1.16(a)(3) and (d), and she was ordered to take three hours of continuing education on confidentiality and on online and social media use.

None of those are advertising rules. Rule 1.6 is the confidentiality rule, and 1.9(c) carries that duty over to former clients. So the most public thing many firms write online, read by every prospective client who checks the stars before calling, is governed by the same duty that governs the file cabinet. I'd settle how a firm answers reviews before touching a keyword.

What should a law firm say back to an unfair review?

The safest answer to an angry review says nothing about the matter, and nothing about whether there was one. Something along these lines: "Our professional rules don't allow us to discuss anyone's legal matter in public, including whether we represented them. If you'd like to talk, please call the office and ask for me." It reads as calm, and it confirms nothing.

The urge to correct the record is strongest when the review is unfair. Wait a day. Have the lawyer whose name is on the matter approve the words, or keep one approved reply for staff to post unchanged. If a review breaks Google's content rules, report it through the profile instead of arguing it out in public.

Two more things belong in the firm's written habits. Google's Maps content policy says merchants may not "Offer incentives – such as payment, discounts, free goods and/or services - in exchange for posting any review or revision or removal of a negative review." A reduced bill in return for taking a post down is exactly that. And the FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, in force since October 21, 2024, bans fake reviews, incentives tied to a particular sentiment, and suppressing reviews through threats or intimidation. A letter meant to frighten a reviewer into deleting a post is the wrong tool.

Asking satisfied clients for a review is fine. Ask everyone at the same point, say at the closing letter, and let them write what they like. The client can say whatever they choose about their own case. The firm's reply can't.

Which Tennessee rule covers a law firm's website?

Rule 7.1 and its comments cover most of what a website needs. Tennessee's lawyer advertising rules were reorganized by a Supreme Court order dated September 1, 2021 (ADM2020-01505), and old Rules 7.2, 7.4 and 7.5 were deleted.

Rule 7.1(b) lets a lawyer advertise "through written, recorded, or electronic communications, including public media," and then adds the line that matters for every page: "Any communication made under this Rule shall include the name and contact information of at least one lawyer or law firm responsible for its content." On a website, the footer is the safe place for it.

Rule 7.1(c) asks for a copy or recording of each ad, kept "for two years after its last dissemination along with a record of when and where it was used." Comment [14] says a website can be retained in line with the Board's guidelines. In practice that means saving a dated copy of a page whenever its wording changes.

The rewrite also moved the specialist limit into the comments. A lawyer "may not communicate that the lawyer is a 'specialist,' practices a 'specialty,' 'specializes in' a particular field," with exceptions for patent and admiralty practice and for certification under Comment [10]. "Nashville DUI specialist" is the kind of title tag an SEO writes without blinking. "DUI defense in Nashville" says the same thing to Google, and the comments allow "practice limited to" wording if you want to be plainer still.

Can a Tennessee lawyer contact accident victims directly?

Not with a targeted letter or message in the first thirty days, unless there's a family or prior professional relationship. Targeted solicitation is a different category from a web page. Under Rule 7.3(c), a solicitation aimed at someone "known to be in need of legal services in a particular matter" has to carry the words "Advertising Material" on the envelope, and at the beginning and end of a recorded or electronic message. Rule 7.3(d) bars that kind of contact within thirty days after an accident or disaster, and after a divorce or separation filing, unless there's a family or prior professional relationship.

A practice-area page about truck accidents isn't aimed at a known person, so as I read the rule it stays on the advertising side. A text message sent to someone whose name came off a crash report is the other side.

One profile for the firm, one per lawyer

Google's Business Profile guidelines treat lawyers as individual practitioners. A public-facing lawyer can have a profile of their own in addition to the firm's, and titles such as "JD, Esq." can appear in the name. What a lawyer shouldn't have is several profiles to cover separate practice areas. The divorce work and the estate work both belong under the one name, with categories and services doing the sorting.

Google's Local Services Ads list lawyer categories such as Criminal lawyer and Disability lawyer, and each comes with business and owner checks and a state bar license check. For markup, schema.org has LegalService for the firm and Attorney as a subtype of it. Both describe a business, so I'd use them on the firm's pages and mark up an individual lawyer's bio as a Person who works for that firm.

If you'd like a second set of eyes on how your firm's profiles and replies read, our review management work starts with exactly that, and you can reach me through the contact page. More on how we work with practices is on the law firms page.

FAQ

How should a lawyer respond to a negative Google review?

Briefly, and without confirming anything about the matter or whether the reviewer was ever a client. Say your professional rules prevent public discussion of any legal matter and invite them to call the office. A Tennessee lawyer was publicly censured in 2025 for replying to reviews with confidential client details.

Can a Tennessee lawyer call themselves a specialist?

Generally no. Since the 2021 amendments, the comments to Tennessee RPC 7.1 bar saying you're a "specialist" or "specialize in" a field, except for patent and admiralty practice and lawyers certified under the route in Comment [10]. Wording such as "practice limited to" is allowed, and plain practice-area names work fine for search.

How long does a Tennessee law firm have to keep copies of its ads?

Two years after the ad was last used. Tennessee RPC 7.1(c) asks for a copy or recording kept along with a record of when and where it ran. Comment [14] lets a website be retained under the Board's guidelines, so saving a dated copy whenever a page's wording changes is a sensible habit.

Can a lawyer have a separate Google profile for each practice area?

No. Google's guidelines say practitioners shouldn't have multiple Business Profiles to cover their specializations. A public-facing lawyer can have one profile of their own alongside the firm's, with titles such as "JD, Esq." in the name, and the categories and services on that profile describe the different kinds of work.

How do I market a new law firm?

Start with the firm's Business Profile and one for each public-facing lawyer, a website that names the responsible lawyer on every page, and a page for each practice area written in your own words. Settle how reviews will be requested and answered before they start arriving, because replies carry confidentiality risk.

Ready to act?

Put any of this to work for you.

Send us the site. A written fix plan follows in one business day.

ReplyOne business day
ProposalWritten · scoped · priced
ContractMonth to month
Proposal request

Tell us what you need

No spam · One business day reply · Month to month